Home › Top 5 Restaurants in Matlacha, Florida Find best Restaurants in Matlacha, Florida, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. BIG Herm's Chicago Style Food US, Matlacha, FL 339933946 Pine Island Rd THAT BBQ PLACE US, Matlacha, FL 339934590 Pine Island Rd Blue Dog Bar & Grill US, Matlacha, FL 339934597 Pine Island Rd Yucatan Waterfront Bar and Grill US, Matlacha, FL 339934875 Pine Island Rd Hooked Island Grill US, Matlacha, FL 339934200 Pine Island Rd