Home › Top 4 Pizza restaurant in Hilton, New York Find best Pizza restaurant in Hilton, New York, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Pontillo's Pizzeria of Hilton US, Hilton, NY 144688 Canning St Salvatore's Pizza US, Hilton, NY 1446875 Lake Ave Carbone’s Pizzeria - Hilton (NY 14468) US, Hilton, NY 14468144 South Ave Caraglio's Pizza US, Hilton, NY 144687 Main St