Home › Top 5 Pizza restaurant in Columbus, Indiana Find best Pizza restaurant in Columbus, Indiana, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Mancino’s Pizza & Grinders - Columbus (IN 47201) US, Columbus, IN 472011301 N National Rd Papa Johns Pizza - Columbus (IN 47201) US, Columbus, IN 472012520 Eastbrook Plz Chicago’s Pizza - Columbus (IN 47201) US, Columbus, IN 472013780 W Jonathan Moore Pike ZwanzigZ Pizza and brewing US, Columbus, IN 472011038 Lafayette Ave Arni's Columbus US, Columbus, IN 472032765 Brentwood Dr