Home › Top 4 Italian restaurant in Surprise, Arizona Find best Italian restaurant in Surprise, Arizona, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant - Surprise (AZ 85374) US, Surprise, AZ 8537413379 W Grand Ave Babbo Italian Eatery - Surprise (AZ 85374) US, Surprise, AZ 8537416433 W Bell Rd Carrabba’s Italian Grill - Surprise (AZ 85374) US, Surprise, AZ 8537414043 W Bell Rd Portofino Ristorante West US, Surprise, AZ 8537812851 W Bell Rd #124