Home › Top 4 Italian restaurant in Key West, Florida Find best Italian restaurant in Key West, Florida, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. New York Pasta Garden US, Key West, FL 330401075 Duval St Roostica US, Key West, FL 330405620 MacDonald Ave La Trattoria Restaurant US, Key West, FL 33040524 Duval St Terrace Roma US, Key West, FL 33040300 Front St