Home › Top 7 Insurance Company in Tuscola, Illinois Find best Insurance Company in Tuscola, Illinois, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Kris Clodfelder - COUNTRY Financial representative US, Tuscola, IL 61953701 E Southline Rd Lighthouse Insurance Agency, Inc. US, Tuscola, IL 61953200 E Southline Rd The Hillard Agency, Inc. Insurance and Real Estate US, Tuscola, IL 61953500 S Main St Sherri Stewart - American Central Insurance Services US, Tuscola, IL 61953304 E Southline Rd APT A Douglas County Farm Bureau US, Tuscola, IL 61953105 N Main St Alora Murphy American Family Insurance US, Tuscola, IL 61953102 W Wilson St John Davis - State Farm Insurance Agent US, Tuscola, IL 61953800 S Embrass Ave