Home › Top 9 Insurance Company in Lima, Ohio Find best Insurance Company in Lima, Ohio, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Lori Kroeger - State Farm Insurance Agent US, Lima, OH 458051617 Allentown Rd #101 Mel Butterfield & Son Insurance Agency, Inc. US, Lima, OH 45801327 W High St Farmers Insurance - Marc Wright US, Lima, OH 458051572 Allentown Rd Ste B Gerber Insurance & Financial Services US, Lima, OH 458051727 Allentown Rd Kesner Insurance Agency Inc US, Lima, OH 458051240 W Market St Erie Insurance Group - Lima (OH 45801) US, Lima, OH 45801115 N Elizabeth St Webb Insurance Agency, Inc. US, Lima, OH 45801212 W High St Wenger Insurance US, Lima, OH 45801200 W North St A Sullivan Insurance US, Lima, OH 45801606 W North St