Home › Top 4 Insurance Company in Lancaster, Ohio Find best Insurance Company in Lancaster, Ohio, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Mitchell Insurance Agency - Lancaster (OH 43130) US, Lancaster, OH 43130121 E 6th Ave #107 Farmers Insurance - Mark Reynolds US, Lancaster, OH 43130118 W Mulberry St Wentz Insurance Agency Inc US, Lancaster, OH 431301601 E Main St Clark Insurance - Lancaster (OH 43130) US, Lancaster, OH 43130414 E Main St # 100