Home › Top 7 Insurance Company in Lancaster, New York Find best Insurance Company in Lancaster, New York, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Weimer Over Agency, Inc. US, Lancaster, NY 1408610 Franklin St Selk Family & Business Insurance & EJ Solomon Taxes US, Lancaster, NY 140868 Fox Trce Thill-Demerly Insurance Agency US, Lancaster, NY 140865329 Broadway Nickel City Insurance Agency US, Lancaster, NY 140865532 Broadway Robert E Schaff LTD Insurance & Real Estate US, Lancaster, NY 1408633 Central Ave Charles Snyder: Allstate Insurance US, Lancaster, NY 140863725 Walden Ave Senior Benefits of New York US, Lancaster, NY 140865775 Broadway