Home › Top 5 Insurance Company in Lady Lake, Florida Find best Insurance Company in Lady Lake, Florida, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. We Insure MLS Group US, Lady Lake, FL 3215913940 US Hwy, 801 E Lady Lake Blvd 441 Building 800 Suite Amerity Financial - Lady Lake (FL 32159) US, Lady Lake, FL 32159510 Co Rd 466 Suite 207 Met Life - Lady Lake (FL 32159) US, Lady Lake, FL 321591126 Bichara Blvd Chris Semans - State Farm Insurance Agent US, Lady Lake, FL 32159122 N Old Dixie Hwy The Bascom Agency, LLC: Allstate Insurance US, Lady Lake, FL 32159418 Teague Trail