Home › Top 9 Insurance Company in Key West, Florida Find best Insurance Company in Key West, Florida, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Metlife Auto & Home - Key West (FL 33040) US, Key West, FL 330403241 Flagler Ave Group Insurance US, Key West, FL 330401100 Simonton St Key West Insurance US, Key West, FL 330403152 Northside Dr Suite 201 United Atlantic Insurance Group, Inc. US, Key West, FL 330403438 Duck Ave Diamond Insurance Partners US, Key West, FL 330403706 N Roosevelt Blvd Garrel Miani Financial Group US, Key West, FL 33040302 Southard St Suite 211 CM SR22 Insurance Group - Key West (FL 33040) US, Key West, FL 330401111 12th St Insurance Office of America (formerly Keys Insurance Agency) US, Key West, FL 330403706 N Roosevelt Blvd Suite 208 Fullers Insurance US, Key West, FL 330401432 Kennedy Dr