Home › Top 4 Insurance Company in Highland Mills, New York Find best Insurance Company in Highland Mills, New York, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Brandi Ware and Associates - Highland Mills (NY 10930) US, Highland Mills, NY 10930500 NY-32 Farm Family Casualty Insurance - Highland Mills (NY 10930) US, Highland Mills, NY 10930500 NY-32 Exemplar International Insurance US, Highland Mills, NY 10930615 Route 32, Penthouse Ryan Crosby - State Farm Insurance Agent US, Highland Mills, NY 10930531 NY-32