Home › Top 7 Insurance Company in Grove City, Ohio Find best Insurance Company in Grove City, Ohio, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Bennett ~ Edgar Insurance Agency, Inc. US, Grove City, OH 431233848 Broadway Brian Roberts - Farmers Insurance Agents US, Grove City, OH 431231608 Gateway Cir Mike McClaskie - State Farm Insurance Agent US, Grove City, OH 431232810 London Groveport Rd Mitchell Insurance Agency US, Grove City, OH 431232204 Stringtown Rd Steve Liskany: Allstate Insurance US, Grove City, OH 431232598 Columbus St Morley Parren Bright Insurance Agency US, Grove City, OH 431233907 Broadway GEICO Insurance Agent - Grove City (OH 43123) US, Grove City, OH 431231730 Stringtown Rd