Home › Top 12 Insurance Company in Columbia, Illinois Find best Insurance Company in Columbia, Illinois, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Shelter Insurance - Beth Batson US, Columbia, IL 622361180 Admiral Weinel Blvd Nolkemper Watkins Insurance US, Columbia, IL 62236808 S Main St suite c Farmers Insurance - Danny Schwartz US, Columbia, IL 62236278 Southwoods Dr Columbia Insurance Group: Allstate Insurance US, Columbia, IL 62236960 Columbia Centre Dr Venhaus Insurance Agency US, Columbia, IL 622361218 Blue Spruce Ln Sippel Insurance Agency US, Columbia, IL 62236212 W Locust St Meyer Insurance Services Inc US, Columbia, IL 62236418 N Main St Taake Insurance Agency LTD US, Columbia, IL 62236300 Wedgewood Ct Mack Risk Management US, Columbia, IL 62236103 McCrosky Professional Park Toby Search - COUNTRY Financial representative US, Columbia, IL 62236105 N Main St Mitch Essert - State Farm Insurance Agent US, Columbia, IL 62236400 Columbia Centre Dr Bruce Doyle - State Farm Insurance Agent US, Columbia, IL 62236100 Veterans Pkwy