Home › Top 5 Insurance Company in Coal City, Illinois Find best Insurance Company in Coal City, Illinois, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Scheer's Insurance Services LLC US, Coal City, IL 60416930 E Division St Trotter & Associates Insurance Group US, Coal City, IL 60416395 S Broadway St Benson Insurance Agency, Inc. US, Coal City, IL 60416155 S Broadway St Onorato Insurance Services US, Coal City, IL 60416335 S Broadway St Dean Tambling - COUNTRY Financial Representative US, Coal City, IL 6041665 E Church St