Home › Top 5 Insurance Company in Carmi, Illinois Find best Insurance Company in Carmi, Illinois, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Shelter Insurance - Carmi (IL 62821) US, Carmi, IL 628211002 Oak St Banterra Insurance - Carmi (IL 62821) US, Carmi, IL 628211310 W Main St Country Financial - Carmi (IL 62821) US, Carmi, IL 62821304 E Robinson St James Cook - State Farm Insurance Agent US, Carmi, IL 628211002 Oak St Dave Matheny - State Farm Insurance Agent US, Carmi, IL 62821122 E Main St