Home › Top 6 Gas Stations in Pleasantville, New York Find best Gas Stations in Pleasantville, New York, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. bp - Pleasantville (NY 10570) US, Pleasantville, NY 1057024 Marble Ave Shell - Pleasantville (NY 10570) US, Pleasantville, NY 10570332 Manville Rd Sinclair - Pleasantville (NY 10570) US, Pleasantville, NY 105702 Pleasantville Rd Sunoco - Pleasantville (NY 10570) US, Pleasantville, NY 10570159 Bedford Rd Exxon - Pleasantville (NY 10570) US, Pleasantville, NY 105701 Pleasantville Rd Phillips 66 - Pleasantville (NY 10570) US, Pleasantville, NY 105701 Broadway