Home › Top 4 Gas Stations in Monticello, New York Find best Gas Stations in Monticello, New York, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Stewart’s Shops - Monticello (NY 12701) US, Monticello, NY 1270112 Forestburgh Rd Citgo - Monticello (NY 12701) US, Monticello, NY 1270166 Pleasant St Exxon - Monticello (NY 12701) US, Monticello, NY 1270137 Raceway Rd Sunoco Gas Station - Monticello (NY 12701) US, Monticello, NY 12701360 E Broadway