Home › Top 8 Gas Stations in Brewster, New York Find best Gas Stations in Brewster, New York, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Shell - Brewster (NY 10509) US, Brewster, NY 105093411 Danbury Rd Sunoco - Brewster (NY 10509) US, Brewster, NY 105091224 NY-22 bp - Brewster (NY 10509) US, Brewster, NY 10509876 E Main St Route 22 Valero Food Mart US, Brewster, NY 105091011 County Rd 50 Valero - Brewster (NY 10509) US, Brewster, NY 10509571 NY-312 XtraMart - Brewster (NY 10509) US, Brewster, NY 10509486 N Main St Exxon - Brewster (NY 10509) US, Brewster, NY 105091569 NY-22 CITGO (Fairfield Food & Fuel Corp.) US, Brewster, NY 10509182 Fairfield Dr