Home › Top 13 Gas Stations in Bay Shore, New York Find best Gas Stations in Bay Shore, New York, with all necessary contact information, including addresses, phone numbers, working hours, map locations, and website links. Mobil - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 11706221 W Main St bp - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 117061490 5th Ave Shell - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 11706515 Montauk Hwy Speedway - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 11706327 W Montauk Hwy Busy Bee Convenience Store US, Bay Shore, NY 117061692 Union Blvd Conoco - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 11706195 Pine Aire Dr Sinclair - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 11706645 E Main St OK Petroleum - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 117061550 Brentwood Rd Empire Service Station US, Bay Shore, NY 117061320 5th Ave CITGO - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 117061310 5th Ave Sunoco Gas Station - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 117061400 Brentwood Rd 76 - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 11706989 Sunrise Hwy VALERO - Bay Shore (NY 11706) US, Bay Shore, NY 117062307 Union Blvd